Quest for the Best iOS Music Player

It’s no secret I cherish music. That passion seeped not only into my physical library in the form of vinyl records but also into my personal projects with the introduction of the Bad Music Hertz website and podcast. It was only a matter of time until that same passion fueled a desire to find the perfect iOS music player.

By “perfect” player, I do not simply mean the app most appealing to the widest audience, or even the most well-rounded app (if that’s what you’re looking for, The Sweet Setup’s article is fantastic). No, what I wished to find in my quest was a niche app that’s unapologetically for people that love actively listening to and collecting music.

To help guide my search, I wrote out specific features and design decisions I would look for. Those being:

None of the above requests were deal-breakers, however. Every single music player I’ve tried thus far fails to address at least one of these points, but plenty of them are still extremely good contenders by meeting the majority. My only deal-breaking requirements were:

Due to the player technically meeting the deal-breaking requirements, the official iOS Music.app will also be included for consideration with the qualifying third-party contenders.

Disqualifications

Even with just a few deal-breaking requirements, many music apps failed to even make it to the starting line. They’re listed below in order of preference:


Qualifying App Showdown

Seven apps survived the disqualification round and continued on to be evaluated over the course of six months. They are detailed below in alphabetical order.

Cs (Formerly Cesium)

Functional, but boring. Its interface is entirely utilitarian with little to no opinionated design in it. If that’s what you’re interested in, it’s the best player of the bunch (especially if you loved the the original iOS 6 Music.app).

Pros

Cons

Doppler

Promising, but still too young and missing too many features to seriously consider.

Pros

Cons

Ecoute

What was previously the gold-standard third-party music app is now a barely maintained shell of its former self, its future as bleak as its last design “update” in 2016. The poor thing needs a roadmap or to be finally put out of its misery.

Pros

Cons

Music.app

Entirely inoffensive and mediocre across the board. Unfortunately, in Apple’s effort to appeal to the widest possible market, they’ve created a bloated app that’s needlessly complicated compared to every other third-party offering. However, to give credit where credit’s due, Music.app easily has the best iPad-optimized app of the lot. Not to mention, most other offerings don’t even support iPad, let alone optimize for the larger display. The only other app of the lot that even supports the iPad is Cs.

Pros

Cons

Picky

Cream of the crop for music selection and sorting, but needs visual work everywhere but the player itself. However, if you have a large library consisting of both singles and albums, this app’s for you.

Pros

Cons

Starling

A visually interesting player view in an otherwise visually dated and functionally compromised app. Needs a redesign to be seriously considered.

Pros

Cons

VOX

What seems at first to be a well-made app quickly reveals it’s nothing more than a delivery vehicle for the company’s “premium” music storage service, leaving the app feeling like nothing more than an upsell trap. Needs to stop being a service delivery vehicle and focus on being an good app to be seriously considered.

Pros

Cons


Awards

Prettiest player: Picky
While Ecoute comes close, I personally find Picky sports the prettiest player of the lot. The player view employs a blurring effect similar to that used in tvOS’s Music.app, resulting in stunning visuals that are sure to keep the discerning eye entertained while listening.
Most interesting player: Starling
While by no means the best player here (it doesn’t even make it to being a good player), there’s no denying the waveform visualization that Starling features on its player view is a fantastic feature, and one I can only hope the others will incorporate at some point. If you enjoy having something visual to look at while listening to music, this and Picky are your best bets.
All-around best iPad experience: Music.app
While Cs’s full-screen album art in the iPad player view is a delight, the rest of the experience on iPad is incredibly disappointing; the iPad version is clearly nothing more than a “blown-up” version of the iPhone app. Music.app since iOS 10, on the other hand, is fully optimized for the large iPad display and shines brilliantly on it. However, if missing the edge-to-edge album art in the iPad player view is a deal breaker, use Cs instead.
Best dark and “true black” mode: Cs
Cs is miles ahead of every other contender with its stupendous dark mode support; there’s not another player on this list that supports true black dark mode, which single-handedly grants Cs the win.
Best album grid: Ecoute
Despite being close to abandonware at this point, Ecoute continues to hold the title as one of the few third-party iOS music players to support album grid view. This is my favorite means of visually searching for an album to play, which means I still continue to use Ecoute, Music.app, and VOX while deciding what to listen to (even if I soon switch to a different app to control the playback). Ecoute won out over Music.app and VOX by simply having a more informed and nuanced design.
Easiest-to-use app: Cs
By far, the biggest complaint I hear the average person lob against Music.app is that it’s too darn confusing. If you share this complaint, look no further than Cs. In terms of UI, Cs is the spiritual successor to the original iOS 6 Music.app. If that was at one point your favorite music player, you’ll feel right at home with Cs.
Largest album art display: Cs
If the largest-possible album art is your goal, then Cs is once again the best available choice. Not only is the album artwork edge-to-edge on iPhone displays, it’s also edge-to-edge on iPad, which makes it feel like you’re holding a 7” record sleeve while listening to records.

Final Verdict

With all awards passed out, it’s time to address my original goal: What is the best iOS music player for me? Was my quest successful?

Unfortunately, no.

I love Cs on my iPhone, but I sometimes want to browse my library with a grid view, so I switch to Ecoute or Music.app. However, on occasion, I want to look at the album art while listening, so I switch back to Picky or Cs. Other times, I’m on my iPad and I’m more or less forced to use Music.app. On rare occasions, I crave motion, so I switch to Starling to see the waveform. After half a year of jumping back and forth between all seven of these players, I’m forced to conclude that the “best” iOS music player simply doesn’t exist yet.

However, that doesn’t mean I’ve given up hope! While Music.app has been more-or-less feature-stagnant since iOS 10, third-party developers of apps like Cs, Picky, and Doppler continue to work tirelessly to bring new and exciting features like “true black” dark mode in Cs and the “Recently added” view in Doppler. The world of quality music players on iOS may be small, but it’s thriving, and hints at great improvements down the road that may finally earn one of them a permanent residence on my Dock. Time will tell which one it is.

Honorable Mention

I could not end without briefly mentioning what I find to be the finest music player available on any platform, tvOS’s Music.app. Not only does it feature an album grid view and dark mode support, but the player view is the most gorgeous and visually captivating of any other player (yes, even better than Picky’s). While it utilizes a blurring effect similar to Picky’s, tvOS’s Music.app subtly mutates the image over time, resulting in lava lamp effect on the blurred image. The result is captivating.